Cream clapboard home with a stone chimney and warmly lit windows beyond a deep autumn lawn and curved bluestone walk.

Both Sides of Greenwood Lake Moved Their Tree Lightings. Here's How the Season Opens Now.

Last year's Greenwood Lake Holiday Festival ended with Mayor Tom Howley leading the countdown to the tree lighting at Winstanley Park. Earlier that afternoon, the Warwick Valley Dispatch reported, the Grinch had been picking family members out of the crowd and sending anyone he judged "naughty" down a kids' slide. The Tappan Zee Bridgemen Brass Quartet played, the Sheahan-Gormley Irish Dance troupe performed, and outdoor heaters kept the beverage area warm into the evening on November 29, 2025.

This year the lake has two tree lightings two days apart, one in each state, and both are on larger grounds than they used to be. The Village of Greenwood Lake has already moved its festival from Waterstone Road to Winstanley Park. Across the state line, West Milford is moving its lighting to Wallisch Homestead for 2026. On the New York side, Winstanley Park now holds most of the Village's November.

Winstanley Park Replaced Waterstone Road

Mayor Howley explained the earlier move to the Dispatch last year. "This event gets better each year," he said, "since the venue was changed from Waterstone Road to Winstanley Park, allowing a much larger celebration area for residents and their guests."

The 2026 Greenwood Lake Holiday Festival runs Saturday, November 28, from noon to 6 p.m. at Ben Winstanley Park on Windermere Avenue. The tree lighting is at 5 p.m. In his weekly message on November 2, the mayor listed this year's lineup: vendors, food trucks, crafts, horse-and-buggy rides, carolers, bonfires and a visit from Santa.

Local businesses still have one date to meet. Vendor and food truck applications are due by November 14, and the Village reviews each one. The Village's posting says it will run a coordinated social media and print campaign to bring shoppers to the park, which matters to a small maker deciding whether to book a table.

The festival opens at noon, and the tree isn't lit until 5. Last year the daytime hours went to the brass quartet, the dancers, the carriage rides and the holiday market, and the lighting closed out the day.

West Milford Moved for More Room and Parking

The New Jersey side of the lake has made the same kind of move this year. According to the West Milford Messenger, the township's tree lighting has grown into a Winter Festival and moves to Wallisch Homestead. The new site has more space and parking while construction continues at Town Hall. The township's flyer gives the address as 65 Lincoln Avenue and labels the location "NEW PLACE!"

The festival runs Monday, November 30, from 5 to 8 p.m., organized by the West Milford Community Services and Recreation Department. Mayor Michele Dale and a special guest will light a newly planted Norway spruce at about 7:30 p.m., according to the Messenger.

The Messenger lists a full evening:

  • The West Milford High School Band, directed by Matthew Gramata and Anthony Paterno, and the high school choir, directed by Dwight Weaver, performing the national anthem and music through the night
  • Boy Scouts presenting the colors, with Girl Scouts and choir members leading a community carol singalong
  • Hot chocolate from the West Milford High School Interact Club and the Rotary Club
  • Food for purchase from DeMarco's Pizzeria and the Brownie Bar Food Truck
  • Craft vendors, ice carving, horse-drawn carriage rides, and dance performances by Precision Dance Academy and Hannah's House of Dance
  • S'mores by the fire, weather and fire conditions permitting

The township's flyer adds pictures with Santa after the lighting, so bring your own camera, plus a kids' scavenger hunt with a prize, a photo booth and a DJ. Children must be with an adult, and there are no drop-offs.

The Two Lightings, Side by Side

Village of Greenwood Lake, NY West Milford, NJ
Day and date Saturday, November 28 Monday, November 30
Hours Noon to 6 p.m. 5 to 8 p.m.
Tree lighting 5 p.m. Evening, about 7:30 p.m. per the Messenger
Location Ben Winstanley Park, Windermere Avenue Wallisch Homestead, 65 Lincoln Avenue
Previous location Waterstone Road Moved for space and parking during Town Hall construction
Lit by Village festival, mayor-led countdown in 2025 Mayor Michele Dale and a special guest
Ride Horse-and-buggy rides Horse-drawn carriage rides

The Village festival takes up a Saturday afternoon during the Thanksgiving weekend. West Milford's is a Monday evening event. Both have carriage rides, Santa and live music, so a family that goes to both gets the same traditions twice, in two settings.

Winstanley Park Hosts a Market a Week Before the Festival

On the Village side, the festival is not the first November event at Winstanley Park. The mayor's November 2 message said the regular farmers market had just wrapped up for the season. It also announced a special Thanksgiving Pop-Up Market at Winstanley Park on Saturday, November 21, for picking up local goods for the holiday table. The same park hosts the Saturday pop-up market and, a week later, the festival.

The remaining dates around the lake through early December:

  1. Sunday, November 15, noon to 2 p.m. The Rumshock Foundation hosts its At Your Service! Celebrity Brunch for Veterans at the Landmark Inn in Warwick. Tickets are $100 per person, reservations are encouraged, and Mayor Howley is listed as one of the servers.
  2. Saturday, November 21. Thanksgiving Pop-Up Market at Winstanley Park.
  3. Saturday, November 28, noon to 6 p.m. Greenwood Lake Holiday Festival, with the tree lit at 5 p.m.
  4. Monday, November 30, 5 to 8 p.m. West Milford Winter Festival and tree lighting at Wallisch Homestead.
  5. Tuesday, December 1, 6:30 to 8 p.m. Holiday Wreath Making Class run by West Milford Community Services & Recreation with NJ Audubon, upstairs at the West Milford Recreation Center. The class costs $55 per person, is open to adults over 25, and has limited space. Each wreath is made from natural materials and designed to provide food for birds. Registration is under the township's 2026 Fall Programs.

Parking on Festival Day Under the Winter Rules

The Village's winter street rules are already in effect. The mayor's November 2 message notes that overnight parking on Village streets is prohibited from November 1 through April 1. Leaf pickup continues every Tuesday, and Village residents can drop off yard waste at the DPW on Saturdays from 9 a.m. to noon.

Dinner After the 5 O'Clock Lighting

With the Village tree lit at 5 p.m., there is still time for dinner on Windermere Avenue. The Village's restaurant directory lists several places within a short walk of the park.

  • Four Brother's Pizza & Deli, 67 Windermere Ave.
  • Trattoria Italiana, 75 Windermere Ave.
  • Murphy's Tavern & Restaurant, 85 Windermere Ave.
  • Village Buzz, 91 Windermere Ave.
  • Karen's Café, 96 Windermere Ave.
  • Sing Loong Kitchen, 102 Windermere Ave.
  • Irish Whisper Bar and Noble Pies, both at 122 Windermere Ave.
  • The Grill Restaurant, 125 Windermere Ave.
  • Planet Pizza, 126 Windermere Ave.

Trattoria Italiana posts Saturday hours of 2 to 9 p.m. on its website, which covers the hours after the lighting on November 28. It serves pizza, pasta, meatballs and chicken dishes for dine-in, takeout or delivery. The same listing shows it closed on Mondays, so plan dinner somewhere else after West Milford's lighting on November 30. On Wallisch Homestead's grounds, DeMarco's Pizzeria and the Brownie Bar Food Truck will be selling food that evening.

For a waterfront dinner, Cove Castle at 13 Castle Court posted fall hours on its website of Friday 4 to 10 p.m., Saturday noon to 10 p.m. and Sunday 11 a.m. to 8 p.m. Its posted Saturday close of 10 p.m. comes five hours after the Village tree is lit.

If you're a Greenwood Lake neighbor who loves this time of year on the lake, or you're thinking about what a home here could mean for your family's holidays to come, I'd be glad to hear from you. Carmela Lopez Borrazas works with clients in English, Spanish and Portuguese, on both sides of the lake. Let's Connect.

Work With Carmela

Expect a full-service real estate experience built on strategy, advocacy, and genuine care. Carmela brings strong market knowledge, skilled negotiation, and hands-on support across luxury and commercial transactions—guiding every step with clarity and confidence while keeping your goals front and center.

Follow Me on Instagram