Pine Island has three fall attractions this October: Thunderbird Farms on Van Sickle Road, Blue Arrow Farm on Glenwood Road, and Pumpkinfest at Pine Island Park. Each one keeps its own hours. Thunderbird covers Saturdays and a few late Friday nights. Blue Arrow covers Sunday afternoons and Wednesday evenings. Pine Island Park has one Monday. All three overlap on exactly one weekend, and it's the one coming up. After Halloween the weekly farm schedules wind down to a few one-off dates, and the one weekly slot that keeps going all year is Sunday morning, indoors on Liberty Corners Road.
Seen that way, the month is easier to plan. You don't have to ask which farm is better. You ask which farm is open in the slot you have free.
The Week, Laid Out by Slot
Here is how a typical October week looks across the three, based on each one's published schedule.
| Day | Thunderbird Farms, 13 Van Sickle Rd | Blue Arrow Farm, 86 Glenwood Rd | Pine Island Park, Kay Rd |
|---|---|---|---|
| Monday | Closed | Closed | Pumpkinfest, Oct 12 only, 11 a.m. to 3 p.m. |
| Tuesday | Closed | Closed | |
| Wednesday | Closed | Fall Concert Series, 4:30 to 9 p.m. | |
| Thursday | Closed | Closed | |
| Friday | 5 to 10 p.m. on Oct 16, 23 and 30 only | Mostly private events; murder mystery dinner Oct 23 | |
| Saturday | Noon to 10 p.m.; Halloween until 8 p.m. | Closed for private events | |
| Sunday | Noon to 3 p.m., except Oct 11 | Family Fun Day market and hayride, noon to 5 p.m., through Oct 25 |
Thunderbird's posted hours took effect October 3, 2026, with Monday through Thursday closed. On the October grid on Blue Arrow Farm's website, Monday, Tuesday and Thursday are marked closed, most Fridays and Saturdays are booked for private events, and Wednesday is a 4:30 to 9 p.m. Fall Concert Series.
So Saturday is Thunderbird's day. Wednesday night belongs to Blue Arrow. Sunday afternoon is the one slot where both are open. On Sundays Thunderbird closes at 3 p.m. and Blue Arrow runs until 5.
Saturdays and Late Nights Belong to Thunderbird
Thunderbird Farms is open from noon to 10 p.m. on Saturdays this October. On Halloween it closes at 8. The main draw is the Haunted Boo Barn and Trails, open on Saturdays plus the three Friday nights: October 16, 23 and 30. Halloween is the exception, with no haunt that night. Thunderbird keeps those Friday nights from 5 to 10 p.m.
Families with younger kids get their own hours. Thunderbird's "Kids No Scare" hours run Saturdays from noon to 5 p.m. and Sundays from noon to 3 p.m., except October 11. That puts the full scare after dark and keeps the daytime for little kids on the same property.
Sunday Afternoons and Wednesday Nights Belong to Blue Arrow
Blue Arrow Farm keeps the Sunday-afternoon farm-market tradition going. Its free Sunday Fun Day farmers market runs from noon to 5 p.m. every Sunday through October 25. It includes vendors, train rides, rescue animals, food, ice cream and outdoor activities, according to the Pick OCNY listing. On the farm's own calendar the Sunday entry is "Family Fun Day Farmers Market and Pumpkin Picking Hayride," and Felix and the Cats play from 1:30 to 4:30 p.m. on the Sundays shown.
Blue Arrow is also the only one of the three that plans for midweek. Its Wednesday Fall Concert Series runs from 4:30 to 9 p.m. Tonight, October 7, it's billed as Yacht Rock Night, hosted by Captain Broadway Freddie and featuring Summer Breeze.
The rest of Blue Arrow's October lines up with the season:
- Trunk or Treat, Sunday, October 18, 11 a.m. to 1 p.m.
- Halloween Murder Mystery Dinner Show, Friday, October 23, 6 to 9 p.m., one of the few Fridays the farm isn't closed for a private event
- Final Sunday market, October 25
The One Weekend Everything Lines Up
Sunday, October 11 and Monday, October 12 is the stretch where Pine Island's three calendars hand off to each other. It's also the one Sunday this month that Thunderbird has closed.
On Sunday, Blue Arrow has most of its October lineup on one day. Octoberfest runs from noon to 5 p.m. A Halloween Paint and Sip runs from 1 to 4 p.m. Felix and the Cats play from 1:30 to 4:30, and polka music from The Poka Buddies closes things out from 4 to 5 p.m.
On Monday, Columbus Day, Pine Island Park has its turn. The Town of Warwick's bulletin for the week of October 5, 2026 confirms PumpkinFest for Monday, October 12, from 11 a.m. to 3 p.m., at Pine Island Park on Kay Road off County Route 1. Admission is $10 cash per participating child. The Pine Island Chamber of Commerce presents the event, according to the Warwick Valley Chamber of Commerce visitors guide. The listed activities are bouncy houses, Touch-A-Tractor, pumpkin and face painting, games and food trucks. The park's giant onion with climbing nets, a slide and the pirate ship are part of it too, and bathrooms are on site.
The Chamber's own Pumpkinfest page still describes last year's event, which was held October 13, 2025. The town bulletin is the current source for the 2026 date. It's the same pattern as last year: the Monday of the Columbus Day weekend.
Thunderbird is back on its regular schedule the following Friday, October 16, with the first of its three late-night Fridays.
Halloween Falls on a Saturday, and Thunderbird Splits It in Two
This year October 31 is a Saturday, which is already Thunderbird's day. The farm is using it for something new: the Monster Munch Halloween Festival, from noon to 5 p.m. It has a children's costume parade at 2 p.m., vendors, food trucks and live music. The regular haunt is off that night. A separate Boo Barn Twilight experience runs from 5 to 8 p.m. instead. The farm's event page lists the date as October 31, 2026.
The 8 p.m. close is two hours earlier than Thunderbird's usual 10 p.m. on Saturdays. On Halloween night the farm calendar ends earlier than on any other Saturday this month.
When the Outdoor Calendars Stop, Sunday Morning Moves Indoors
Here's how the season winds down. Blue Arrow's Sunday market ends October 25. Thunderbird's posted schedule covers October only. That leaves one fixed weekly slot in Pine Island: Warwick's Indoor Farm Market at 115 Liberty Corners Road, open Sundays from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. all twelve months of the year, as the Warwick Valley Dispatch reported in May 2026.
Its hours already sit on the Sunday schedule through October. It opens two hours before Blue Arrow and Thunderbird and closes as their afternoons get going. In November it becomes the whole Sunday schedule.
The Dispatch's profile names two vendors that hold up well into winter. Dan Madura Farms grows eight varieties of mushrooms year-round, from oyster to shiitake, and also sells pea and sunflower microgreens along with greens and root vegetables. Liquid Mercantile, a farm distillery from Pine Bush that the paper called a recent addition, distills apple brandy on site. It also makes a sour cherry nocino from black walnuts foraged on its property and a coffee vodka made with beans from local roasters, including Urban Beaver.
What's on the Books for November
Blue Arrow doesn't fully go quiet. Its website lists Stiff Upper Lip on November 5, line dancing on November 7 and The Harrisons on November 21. Times haven't been posted yet.
In Edenville, Edenville General Store at 240 Pine Island Turnpike is open seven days a week. The Dispatch reported in June 2026 that the store is adding a mobile outdoor stage and shifting its food service toward specialty smoked meats and event buffets.
The Warwick Valley Chamber's guide lists a Pine Island Tree Lighting but gives no 2026 date yet. In the village, the same guide lists the Warwick Valley Gardeners' Christmas Tree Lighting at Railroad Green and the Home for the Holidays Kick Off for November 22, 2026. Until the Pine Island date is posted, the Sunday 10 a.m. market on Liberty Corners Road is the one weekly fixture you can count on after Halloween.
If you have family visiting for the Columbus Day weekend and want help fitting Octoberfest and Pumpkinfest into the same two days, Carmela Lopez Borrazas is happy to share her own Pine Island October plan. Let's Connect.